Amanita Muscaria vs. Psilocybin Mushrooms: What’s the Difference?

The world of psychedelic mushrooms is vast, fascinating, and often misunderstood. Two of the most talked-about varieties today are amanita muscaria and psilocybin mushrooms. While both are commonly grouped under the umbrella of “magic mushrooms,” they are chemically, historically, and experientially very different.

If you’re researching these substances for education, curiosity, or harm-reduction purposes, understanding the distinction is crucial. In this in-depth guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about amanita muscaria vs. psilocybin mushrooms, including their effects, active compounds, safety profiles, legality, and how they compare as a mushroom drug.

Whether you’re new to psychedelic culture or an experienced explorer, this guide will help you make informed decisions.

What Is Amanita Muscaria?

Amanita muscaria is one of the most recognizable mushrooms in the world. With its bright red cap and white spots, it’s the classic “fairy tale” mushroom often seen in folklore, video games, and holiday imagery.

But despite its whimsical appearance, amanita muscaria is not the same as psilocybin mushrooms.

Active Compounds in Amanita Muscaria

Unlike psilocybin mushrooms, amanita muscaria does not contain psilocybin. Instead, its primary psychoactive compounds are:

• Muscimol

• Ibotenic acid

These compounds affect the brain differently than psilocybin. Muscimol primarily acts on GABA receptors, producing sedative, dissociative, and dream-like effects rather than the classic psychedelic visuals associated with magic mushrooms.

Effects of Amanita Muscaria

The effects of amanita muscaria can include:

• Altered perception

• Dream-like states

• Euphoria or dysphoria

• Sedation

• Muscle twitching

• Confusion

• Nausea (especially if improperly prepared)

Unlike psychedelic mushrooms that contain psilocybin, amanita muscaria often produces a more dissociative and intoxicating experience rather than a visual, introspective psychedelic journey.

What Are Psilocybin Mushrooms?

Psilocybin mushrooms, often referred to as magic mushrooms, are fungi that contain the psychoactive compounds:

• Psilocybin

• Psilocin

When consumed, psilocybin converts into psilocin in the body, which interacts primarily with serotonin receptors (5-HT2A receptors) in the brain. This interaction produces the classic psychedelic experience.

Common Types of Psilocybin Mushrooms

Some popular species include:

• Psilocybe cubensis

• Psilocybe semilanceata

• Psilocybe azurescens

Each psilocybin mushroom species can vary in potency, but they all share similar core psychoactive effects.

Effects of Psilocybin Mushrooms

The effects of psilocybin mushrooms may include:

• Visual distortions or hallucinations

• Heightened emotions

• Spiritual or mystical experiences

• Increased creativity

• Deep introspection

• Altered sense of time

• Enhanced connection to surroundings

Compared to amanita muscaria, psilocybin mushrooms are generally considered more predictably psychedelic.

Amanita Muscaria vs. Psilocybin Mushrooms: Key Differences

Let’s break down the major differences between these two mushroom drug categories.

1. Active Compounds

• Amanita muscaria → Muscimol & ibotenic acid

• Psilocybin mushrooms → Psilocybin & psilocin

This is the most fundamental difference. They act on completely different neurotransmitter systems in the brain.

2. Type of Experience

• Amanita muscaria → Sedative, dissociative, dream-like

• Psilocybin mushrooms → Psychedelic, visual, emotional, introspective

When people think of psychedelic mushrooms, they are usually referring to psilocybin mushrooms—not amanita muscaria.

3. Visual Effects

• Amanita muscaria: Mild or inconsistent visuals

• Psilocybin mushrooms: Strong visual hallucinations and distortions

4. Safety Profile

Both substances carry risks, but they differ:

• Amanita muscaria can cause nausea and neurotoxic symptoms if improperly prepared.

• Psilocybin mushrooms may cause anxiety, panic, or “bad trips,” especially in high doses.

Neither should be treated casually as a recreational mushroom drug.

5. Cultural History

• Amanita muscaria appears in Siberian shamanic traditions and European folklore.

• Psilocybin mushrooms were used ceremonially by Indigenous cultures in Mesoamerica.

Are Amanita Muscaria and Psilocybin Mushrooms Both “Magic Mushrooms”?

The term magic mushrooms is commonly used to describe psilocybin mushrooms.

Technically, amanita muscaria is psychoactive, but it is not considered a traditional psychedelic mushroom because it does not produce the same serotonin-based hallucinogenic effects.

In modern usage:

• “Magic mushrooms” = Psilocybin mushrooms

• Amanita muscaria = Psychoactive mushroom, but not psilocybin-based

This distinction is important for safety and expectations.

Legality in the United States

The legality of both substances varies.

Psilocybin Mushrooms

In the U.S., psilocybin is federally classified as a Schedule I substance. However:

• Some cities have decriminalized it.

• Oregon and Colorado have legalized supervised psilocybin programs.

• Laws are rapidly evolving.

Amanita Muscaria

Amanita muscaria is not federally scheduled in the same way as psilocybin. However, regulations may vary by state.

Always check local laws before purchasing or consuming any mushroom drug.

Safety and Harm Reduction

Whether discussing amanita muscaria or psilocybin mushrooms, harm reduction is critical.

For Psilocybin Mushrooms

• Start with a low dose.

• Avoid mixing with alcohol or other drugs.

• Be in a safe environment.

• Have a sober sitter if inexperienced.

For Amanita Muscaria

• Proper preparation is crucial.

• Incorrect dosing can lead to unpleasant symptoms.

• Effects can be unpredictable.

Neither psychedelic mushrooms nor amanita muscaria should be used by individuals with certain mental health conditions without professional guidance.

Medical and Therapeutic Research

Psilocybin Mushrooms

Psilocybin is currently being studied for:

• Depression

• PTSD

• Anxiety

• End-of-life distress

• Substance use disorders

Clinical trials have shown promising results under supervised conditions.

Amanita Muscaria

Research is more limited. While muscimol affects GABA receptors, it has not been studied as extensively for therapeutic use as psilocybin mushrooms.

This difference in research backing is another major distinction.

Comparing the Experience: Which Is Stronger?

“Stronger” depends on what you mean.

• In terms of psychedelic intensity, psilocybin mushrooms are typically stronger.

• In terms of sedation or intoxication, amanita muscaria may feel heavier or more disorienting.

Many experienced users report that psilocybin mushrooms offer more clarity and insight, while amanita muscaria can feel more confusing or physically uncomfortable.

Risks and Side Effects

Amanita Muscaria Risks

• Nausea and vomiting

• Sweating

• Muscle twitching

• Confusion

• Delirium in high doses

Psilocybin Mushroom Risks

• Anxiety or panic

• Paranoia

• Elevated heart rate

• Risk of triggering latent psychiatric conditions

No mushroom drug is risk-free.

Why People Confuse Amanita Muscaria with Psilocybin Mushrooms

The confusion largely comes from:

• Both being mushrooms

• Both having psychoactive effects

• Cultural imagery (especially red-and-white mushroom symbolism)

However, chemically and experientially, they are entirely different substances.

Choosing the Right Experience

If someone is specifically looking for:

• Visuals

• Emotional breakthroughs

• Spiritual exploration

They are usually referring to psilocybin mushrooms, not amanita muscaria.

If someone is curious about:

• Dream-like states

• Dissociation

• Sedative experiences

They may be researching amanita muscaria.

Understanding your intention is critical.

Responsible Purchasing and Quality Matters

If you are exploring cannabis or legal plant-based products, quality and sourcing matter.

At Get Bud Online, we prioritize:

• Lab-tested products

• Reliable shipping across the U.S.

• Discreet packaging

• High-quality cannabis strains

While laws around psychedelic mushrooms continue to evolve, many customers interested in alternative experiences also explore premium cannabis products for relaxation, creativity, and wellness.

If you’re curious about enhancing your experience in legal ways, browse our curated cannabis selection today.

Final Thoughts: Amanita Muscaria vs. Psilocybin Mushrooms

To summarize:

• Amanita muscaria contains muscimol and ibotenic acid.

• Psilocybin mushrooms contain psilocybin and psilocin.

• They act on different brain receptors.

• They produce entirely different experiences.

• They have different safety considerations and legal statuses.

When people talk about magic mushrooms or psychedelic mushrooms, they are almost always referring to psilocybin mushrooms—not amanita muscaria.

Education is the foundation of safe exploration. Whether you’re researching a mushroom drug out of curiosity or exploring legal cannabis alternatives, staying informed helps you make smarter, safer choices.

If you’re looking for premium cannabis products, THC concentrates, weed edibles, or marijuana flower delivered discreetly in the U.S., visit GetBudOnline.com and explore our collection today.

Stay informed. Stay safe. Choose quality.

References:

Wikipedia. (2026, February 10). Amanita muscaria. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amanita_muscaria 

Ducharme, J. (2024, October 4). Is It Legal to Buy Psilocybin Gummies in the USA?. Available at: https://time.com/7032706/are-mushroom-edibles-safe-legal/

Web MD. (2026). Psilocybin – Uses, Side Effects, and More. Available at: https://www.webmd.com/vitamins/ai/ingredientmono-1654/psilocybin 

Dr. Dan Roden, MD